How to Choose a Butt Plug – 5 Tips You Should Know

Using a butt plug is a fantastic experience. It can be used for foreplay to prepare for anal sex or as a standalone form of pleasure. But choosing the right butt plug from the many available could be a bit overwhelming, especially for people who first step into the sex toy world.

Well, this is not a big issue. I’ve got you covered with five essential tips for how to choose a butt plug. As long as you follow these tips, things will work out.

What Are Butt Plugs?

Butt plugs are sex toys designed to be inserted into the rectum for pleasure. Unlike dildos, which are often used for thrusting, butt plugs are meant to stay in place once inserted, providing a sense of fullness and stimulation to the anal area.

Benefits of Using a Butt Plug

Using a butt plug can offer several benefits, enhancing both solo and partnered sexual experiences. Here are some of the key advantages:

1. Enhanced Pleasure

Butt plugs can heighten pleasure by stimulating sensitive nerve endings in the rectal area. This can lead to more intense orgasms and a deeper sense of satisfaction.

2. Increased Comfort During Anal Sex

For those who enjoy anal sex, using a butt plug can help prepare the body by gently stretching the muscles and making penetration more comfortable.

3. Improved Prostate Health

For men, using a butt plug to stimulate the prostate can promote better prostate health. Regular stimulation can help prevent certain prostate issues and improve sexual function.

4. Spicing Up Sexual Activities

Incorporating a butt plug into sexual activities can add a new layer of excitement and variety. It can be used during foreplay, sex, or even while performing daily activities for a secret thrill.

5. Strengthening Pelvic Floor Muscles

Using a butt plug can also help strengthen the pelvic floor muscles, which can lead to better control and stronger orgasms.

How to Choose a Butt Plug

1. Determine Your Focus

First and foremost, it’s essential to determine your focus when choosing a butt plug. Do you want to stimulate the prostate or the entrance to the anus? Knowing what you want to achieve will help you choose the right shape, size, and material.

Anal Plugs for Entrance to the Anus

There are many nerve endings in the anal opening, and it is located near both male and female g-spots. Butt plugs are designed to insert into the anus and stay there for a while. The type of toy has a bulb head with a thin neck connected to a flared base that prevents it from getting too far inside the body.

Anal plugs come in various shapes and sizes, which can enhance anal sensation in different ways. Also, they are gender-neutral toys suitable for everyone.

Thrusting Anal Toys for Stimulate the Prostate

Also known as prostate massager, this anal sex toy is specifically designed for prostate stimulation.

Unlike traditional butt plugs that remain stationary, it often features a powerful motor to make the shaft move back and forth, which can provide deeper stimulation and pleasure.

2. Size Matters

When buying a butt plug, there are two points you need to think about: 1) how far inside do you want to go? 2) how big do you want your anus to stretch?

Complete Beginners – Extra Small Butt Plugs

If you are completely new to any kind of anal penetration and have a sensitive body, then start with an extra small butt plug. Extra small plugs are usually under 1 inch in diameter, making them very easy to insert into your anus.

This level of size plug might not provide much stimulation, but it can help you decide whether you enjoy anal play or not.

Beginners – Small Butt Plugs

Small plugs are generally in the size range of 1-1.25 inches in diameter, making itself a perfect startup for beginners.

If you are not afraid to put items down there or have already explored this secret area with your finger, then you can start with a small plug to get a bit more stimulation.

Some Anal Experience – Medium Butt Plugs

For individuals with some anal play experience, it’s very recommended to choose a medium size butt plug since it is generally in the size range of 1.25-1.5 inches, which can offer more incredible sensation. 

Medium-size butt plugs can offer more fullness and stimulation than small plugs.

Advanced Users – Huge Butt Plug

If you have extensive anal sex experience and are looking for more intense stimulation, In that case, you may want to try a giant butt plug.

With 1.5 inches or wider in diameter, huge butt plugs are more suited for people who have used medium butt plugs or have experience with anal sex with a penis or dildo.

3. Shape Is Important

Usually, a butt plug comes in four elements: the top, the drop-off point, the neck, and the flared base.

Tapered, Not Sharp

A butt plug often features a tapered or water-drop design which is easy to insert. Still, some have a sharp tip that might cause pain or uncomfortable during use. So in order to avoid unexpected situations, it’s better to choose a gentle top butt plug to begin your journey. 

Tapered Drop-off Point

The top of a plug isn’t the only place it needs a taper. The drop-off from the bulb to the neck also needs a taper. A butt plug with a drop-off point body can help stretch your sphincters easily, and it also allows you to let your ass relax.

The Neck

The neck should be at least 1.5cm long, but ideally around 3 to 4cm. This length allows your internal and external sphincters to fit comfortably around the neck of the plug.

A shorter neck can cause the internal sphincter to partially rest on the bulb, which will make the plug difficult to relax and keep in place. Additionally, a thinner neck allows your sphincter muscles to relax, while a thicker neck will provide more pressure on your sphincter, making it more stimulating.

Flared or T-bar Base

The base should be a T-bar or flared to prevent the plug from being sucked in. Plus, the base should be wider than the bulb.

A flared base rubs against your buttocks when you walk around, while a T-bar base butt plug sits snugly between your cheeks.

4.Choose the Right Material

Butt plugs vary from material to material. You can find high-quality butt plugs that are made of non-porous materials like silicone, glass, and stainless steel. Also, you can find there are a lot of affordable plugs that are made of porous materials, such as rubber, TPE, and jelly.

Different materials provide different sensations, so if you’re sensitive to experience, pay attention to what it is made of when selecting a butt plug.

Silicone Butt Plugs

Silicone butt plugs are considered the safest and most comfortable option among all soft butt plug materials. They are easy to use and clean, making them an ideal option for beginners.

Additionally, this material is non-porous, which means it won’t trap fluid and hide bacteria, so it is more hygienic than porous materials.

It is essential to note that silicone-based lubricants should not be used with silicone butt plugs; water-based lube is the most appropriate choice.

Metal Butt Plugs

Metal butt plugs are a great choice for those who want a more intense and powerful anal stimulation. They are smooth and sturdy and can offer incredible sensual sensations.

If you’re fond of temperature play, you definitely can’t miss metal butt plugs. Due to the properties of metal, they can be boiled in water or cooled in a refrigerator without compromising their lifespan, which makes them a perfect sex toy for sensual play.

Metal butt plugs are generally safe, but not absolutely. It depends on what kind of metal material you choose.

Body-safe metal materials:

1. Stainless Steel
2. Aluminum
3. Titanium
4. Gold-Plated
5. Silver

Unsafe metal materials:

1. Nickel
2. Lead
3. Cadmium
4. Copper
5. Uncoated Brass and Zinc

Glass Anal Toy

When we mention glass anal toys, we are talking about durable and highly resistant to shattering borosilicate glass.

Many glass butt plugs come in a variety of attractive designs and colors, adding visual appeal to their functionality. Their smooth and slick surface can enhance comfort and ease of insertion.

Glass can be heated or cooled to different temperatures, adding an extra dimension of sensation during use. Besides, it is compatible with all types of lubricants, including silicone, water-based, and oil-based.

But glass butt plugs tend to be heavier than those made from silicone or other materials, which might be uncomfortable for some users during extended wear.

Which One Is Suitable for Beginners: Metal, Glass or Silicone Butt Plugs?

We recommend trying a variety of different butt plugs to experience various sensations.

For beginners, starting with a silicone butt plug is a good option. Silicone plugs are lighter compared to metal and glass plugs, allowing for longer wear without causing fatigue. Additionally, silicone is softer and more flexible, making it an ideal choice for those new to anal play.

If you’re seeking more intense stimulation, metal and glass butt plugs are excellent choices. Due to their weight, these plugs provide firm pressure around the rectum, offering incredible pleasure. However, the weight can also be a drawback, as wearing metal or glass plugs for extended periods may cause discomfort.

5. Lubrication Is Essential

Lubrication is essential when using a butt plug. Most anal plugs, even those made of smooth glass and stainless steel, have some friction. Without lubricant, there’s a high risk of injuring the anal area.

To ensure a smooth and safe experience, many sex experts and anal play enthusiasts recommend using lube. But the benefits of lubrication don’t stop there.

Some sex toys are porous and can be damaged during use. Lubricant acts as a protective barrier, helping to keep your toys in good condition so you don’t have to replace them frequently.

Additionally, experts suggest that lube can enhance the effectiveness of a butt plug. With everything smooth and friction-free, the butt plug can provide maximum pleasure.

However, choosing the right lubricant is crucial. It’s important to consider the base ingredient and its compatibility with your butt plug.

There are three main types of lubricants available: water-based, silicone-based, and oil-based. Each type has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, depending on the material of the butt plug you’re using.

Water-Based Lubricants

Water-based lubricants are the safest option for beginners, as they are less likely to cause allergic reactions and are compatible with most materials. They are also easy to clean up. However, they evaporate quickly and may require frequent reapplication.

Silicone-Based Lubricants

Silicone-based lubricants are excellent for penetration, making any anal play more pleasurable. They last longer than water-based lubricants, which tend to be absorbed by the anus relatively quickly. With silicone-based lube, you won’t have to worry about it disappearing, even during extended play sessions.

However, this type of lube is not compatible with silicone plugs, as it can cause the material to disintegrate. Despite this, silicone-based lube remains a great choice for all other types of anal play. Its thick consistency means a little goes a long way, and it’s incredibly slick and long-lasting, allowing for a prolonged and enjoyable experience.

Also Read:

Guide of Sex Lube

Oil-Based Lubricants

For smooth penetration, oil-based lubricants are an excellent choice. They provide a silky texture that lasts a long time and doesn’t evaporate as quickly as water-based lubes. However, oil-based lubricants can degrade the integrity of latex condoms.

While they are compatible with other materials, they can be challenging to clean up, often leaving stains and attracting bacteria.

To avoid any complications during play, always check the lube’s compatibility with your toy. Read the labels and follow the instructions. With proper care, you can enhance your anal play experience and achieve a mind-blowing orgasm.

Are There Any Risks of Using Butt Plugs??

While many people can safely enjoy butt plugs, there are potential risks associated with their use. Being aware of these risks and taking appropriate precautions can help minimize any potential harm. Here are some common risks to consider:

1. Injury: Improper use or choosing a plug that’s too large can lead to tears, abrasions, or other injuries to the rectal tissue.

2. Infection: Not properly cleaning the butt plug before and after use can introduce harmful bacteria, leading to infections. Using lubricants that are not body-safe can also cause irritation and increase infection risk.

3. Rectal Damage: Vigorous or careless use might cause damage to the rectum or the anal sphincter, potentially leading to long-term issues such as incontinence.

4. Foreign Body Retention: If a butt plug doesn’t have a flared base or is not designed for anal use, there’s a risk it could be fully inserted and become difficult to remove, necessitating medical intervention.

5. Allergic Reactions: Some materials used in butt plugs, such as certain types of rubber or latex, can cause allergic reactions in some individuals.

6. Nerve Damage: Excessive or improper use could potentially lead to nerve damage, resulting in numbness or loss of sensation.

If you want to know more info about the risk of using butt plug，Check out the authoritative report from Medical News Today ：What are the risks of anal sex?

Hold on. Cleaning it after use might be a good idea?

Also Read：

How to Clean Anal Sex Toys

Frequenly People Ask and Question

References

Healthline,  Updated on Feb 3, 2022

Conclusion

Thank you for sticking with me until the end. I believe you now have the skills to choose the perfect butt plug.

While choosing the right butt plug may seem overwhelming at first, following these five tips will make the process easier. By keeping these tips in mind, you’ll be able to find the perfect match for you or your partner.