7 Best Gay Sex Toys: Real Tested Review

Last Updated on June 2, 2025 by Nikita

Finding the right sex toy as a gay man can be a little overwhelming—there are so many options, and let’s be honest, not everything out there is worth your money. I’ve spent the last few months testing some of the most talked-about toys for gay men. Some were amazing, others… not so much.

Below, I’m breaking down my personal experience with each toy—what I loved, what I didn’t, and whether I’d actually recommend it. This is not a commercial. Just an honest look from someone who actually used these toys

1.Anesidora Large Vibrating Butt Plug 3 Sizes Silicone

This plug isn’t joking around with its size. The girth of the XL fills you up quickly and completely, and if you’re not properly warmed up, it can feel intimidating. I had to take my time with warm-up toys before I could comfortably insert it, but once it was in, the sensation was incredibly satisfying.

The long, tapered neck and flared base are thoughtful design features that help keep it in place. I even wore it around the house for about an hour to test comfort and security, and to my surprise, it stayed snug and didn’t shift—though the weight becomes noticeable after a while.

One downside I noticed: because of the toy’s size, it can be uncomfortable for extended wear, especially if you’re standing or walking for a long time. It presses on the pelvic floor in a way that can become a little fatiguing after 30-45 minutes. Not painful, just… a little much.

There are 7 vibration modes, ranging from steady to pulsating patterns. The vibrations are strong enough to be felt deep inside, especially if you’re squeezing around the plug, but they’re not the most powerful I’ve experienced. They’re more buzzy than rumbly, which may or may not work for you depending on your preferences.

Price： 37.99

Pros:

• Excellent build quality
• Impressive fullness
• Variety of vibration patterns
• Easy to clean

Cons:

• Not beginner-friendly

Shop the Best Large Butt Plug from Anesidora

Also Read: 8 Best Inflatable Butt Plugs

2.Lighting – Electro Shock Butt Plug With Remote

The size—76mm long and 36mm wide—makes this toy clearly designed for experienced anal players. Beginners should probably stay away unless you’re ready to take things slow and use lots of lube. The shape is classic: bulbous body, tapered neck, and a flared base that sits comfortably once inserted.

The electro-stimulation is what I was most excited (and nervous) about. I’ve dabbled in mild e-stim before, but nothing quite like this. When used properly (with plenty of lube and set to the lower settings), the pulses created a unique tingling, almost throbbing feeling that enhanced my arousal.

That said, this feature isn’t for everyone. If you’ve never tried electro play before, this might be a bit intense for a first experience. And on higher settings, the pulses bordered on uncomfortable—especially when used continuously.

Charging took about 90 minutes and gave me roughly 60–75 minutes of playtime. USB charging is convenient, and the port is discreetly hidden under a soft silicone flap. No complaints here.

Price： 37.99

Pros:

• Strong vibrations and unique electro-stimulation
• Great for advanced users
• Remote control adds versatility
• Waterproof and easy to clean

Cons:

• Vibrations are loud—not suitable for public play

Shop the Best Electro Shock Sex Toys Here

Best Prostate Massager ：Giddi Thor Rotating Prostate Massager

The head is thick and somewhat blunt, which made it difficult to slide in smoothly even with a generous amount of lube. I had to take my time and warm up with a smaller plug first. Even with that prep, it still felt like a bit of a struggle. If you’re new to prostate play or not used to girth, this could be intimidating.

Once it was fully inserted, though, it created a satisfyingly full feeling. The way the toy curves allows it to hug the prostate tightly, which turned out to be both a good and a bad thing

Thor’s rotating head is where the magic happens—or at least, where it’s supposed to. There are three rotation speeds, and they do hit deep. When it locks into the right angle, it creates a unique, almost swirling pressure on the prostate that I haven’t felt with many other toys.

Cleaning is straightforward thanks to the waterproof design and smooth silicone. Just rinse with warm water and soap, and it’s good to go. Charging is via USB and takes a couple hours. Battery life seems solid—I got about 70 minutes on a single charge with a mix of vibration and rotation settings.

Price： $58.49

Pros:

• Deep, rotating p-spot stimulation
• Strong, rumbly vibrations
• Independent control of motors
• Remote control for easy play
• High-quality materials and waterproof design

Cons:

• Blunt tip and girthy size make insertion tricky

Check More Best Thrusting Prostate Massager from Anesidora

Also Read: The 7 Best Tips for Using a Prostate Massager

Best Beads：Anesidora Beads Dildo Vibrating 10.8 Inches

It’s long, beaded, and has a slightly curved design. The silicone is incredibly soft and feels great in the hand—definitely premium quality. It has some give, but it’s still firm enough to stay in place when inserted.

Because of the increasing bead size, inserting the toy can actually feel like a mini workout. I had to go bead by bead, taking breaks between some of the larger ones. With enough lube and patience, it became manageable—but I wouldn’t recommend this for someone brand new to anal play.

Even halfway in, the fullness is very noticeable, and once you reach the bigger beads, it borders on overwhelming (in both good and challenging ways).

The 10 vibration modes range from soft pulses to full-on rumbles. I personally found three or four settings that hit the sweet spot. The lower-intensity ones are great for warm-up, while the higher ones gave me some pretty strong involuntary contractions. So If you’re into deep anal play and want more than just vibration at the base, this is probably going to blow your mind.

Price： $44.99

Pros:

• Deep vibrations along the full length thanks to triple motors
• High-quality silicone and ergonomic design
• 10 versatile vibration modes
• Quiet, waterproof, and USB rechargeable
• Great for advanced users who love fullness and intensity

Cons:

• No remote control—everything is controlled on the base

Shop the Best Anal Beads from Anesidora

Also Read：7 Best Anal Beads

Best Fantasy Toy ：Bronco Ebony Horse Ass Stroker

This toy looks wild. The dark, glossy silicone and exaggerated anatomy definitely cater to a specific fantasy. If that appeals to you, you’ll probably be impressed right away. It’s also worth noting that the silicone feels incredibly soft and smooth right out of the box. No weird chemical smells, and it has that plush, almost “skin-like” feel that high-end toys usually offer.

The inner canal has a surprisingly intense texture. The first time I used it, I actually had to apply more lube than usual because the stroker gripped me so tightly. That can be a good or bad thing, depending on your preference. I’d describe it as a high-suction stroker—it almost pulls you in, especially if you cover the back opening to increase pressure.

Once I got into a rhythm, it provided some great stimulation. The textures inside aren’t overly complex, but they’re deep enough to feel every stroke. It’s more about pressure and suction than complex patterns. After a few sessions, I found it best for slower, more deliberate use rather than fast, aggressive strokes—it’s just too tight and short for heavy thrusting, at least for me.

If you’re into horseplay fantasies or just want something that’s not the typical “mouth or ASSS” stroker, it’ll likely hit the right notes for you.

Price：$66.49

Pros:

• Unique, bold fantasy design
• Soft, body-safe silicone
• Tight, high-suction feel
• Easy to clean and maintain
• Great for slow, immersive play

Cons:

• No built-in grip or base

Check More Fantasy Pocket Pussy、Animal Fleshlight from Anesidora

Best Penis Vibrator：Helmet – Vibrating Adjustable Male Toy App Control

Unboxing The Helmet, I was a little surprised by how compact it was. It’s sleek and minimal, with a matte black silicone finish that feels high-quality and body-safe. There’s no weird rubbery smell, which I’ve unfortunately encountered with cheaper toys.

The toy fits snugly over the head and upper shaft of the penis, and thanks to its soft, stretchy silicone, it adjusts comfortably to different girths. But I’ll say right away—this toy isn’t going to work for everyone. If you’re especially thick or long, it may feel too tight or too shallow.

When used hands-free—say, while watching porn or during oral—it does create a nice buzzing warmth that builds up arousal. It doesn’t move like a stroker, and there’s no suction effect, so don’t expect thrusting or piston-like action. But when timed with other sensations, like oral play or partnered touch, it definitely enhances things.

The toy works with the Remote app, which offers tons of control. You can design custom vibration patterns, sync it to music, or let your partner control it remotely. I tested the long-distance feature with my partner—he played DJ from the other room—and it worked flawlessly.

Price：$37.99

Pros:

• Strong, rumbly vibrations
• Compact and travel-friendly
• Lovense app offers tons of remote control features
• Good for solo or partnered play
• Easy to clean and waterproof

Cons:

• Doesn’t stroke or thrust—vibes only

Shop the Best Penis Vibrator from Anesdiora

Also Read：15 Best Penis Vibrators

Best Tunnel Ass Toy ：Dragon Fantasy Hollow Butt Plug

The colors are vibrant and swirled in a way that’s genuinely beautiful. It almost looks like a prop from a sci-fi film—if that prop were made to stretch your ass open.

To insert the plug, you have to squeeze the “petals” together tightly and then push it in. Sounds simple in theory, but in practice, it’s a bit tricky. The silicone resists staying pinched, so I had to keep one hand holding the base tight while using the other to guide it in. This process took some trial and error. Doing it solo added to the challenge—honestly, it would be easier with a partner.

Once it was fully in and the petals expanded, though, the sensation was amazing. It gave me that “filled up” feeling I crave, but with a unique twist: the open tunnel in the center creates a strange and surprisingly pleasant feeling of airflow or even subtle pressure changes. It’s unlike anything I’ve felt from a regular plug or dildo.

One of the most exciting features is the hollow tunnel. I experimented with a few things—temperature play (pouring lukewarm water through), light teasing with fingers, and even using a small vibe inside the plug while it was inserted. That “breeze” people talk about? It’s real. It’s a subtle sensation but adds a weirdly erotic thrill, like your body’s being gently exposed in a new way.

Price：$37.99

Pros:

• Soft, body-safe silicone
• Visually stunning and uniquely designed
• Strong “full” sensation with expanding petals
• Hollow tunnel allows for creative play
• Comfortable base for extended wear

Cons:

Can be difficult to insert solo

Check More Hollow Butt Plug、Fantasy Butt Plug Here