Best Butt Plug Tails – Tested by Sexpert
Let’s be real—who doesn’t enjoy a little butt play? Even if some folks are hesitant to admit it, anal stimulation can be incredibly intense and pleasurable. That’s why toys like prostate beads and butt plugs have become such popular choices. Both are fantastic for enhancing your orgasms, but there’s only one that lets you do it in style. Enter the butt plugs with tails—a unique and fun twist on traditional anal toys that don’t get nearly enough attention.
But if they’re so awesome, why don’t we see them more often? The truth is, finding the right one can be a bit tricky
Best Design – Anesidora Faux Fur Fox Tail Butt Plug
The Anesidora Deluxe Faux Fox Tail butt plug is a hefty piece of equipment, featuring a beautifully soft faux fox tail. The plug itself offers 4 inches of insertable length . The tail is ombre-colored for a realistic look and is incredibly plush to the touch.
The plug is crafted from smooth, polished stainless steel, giving it both weight and durability. These features alone make the Deluxe Faux Fox Tail a top choice for anyone looking to spice up their play.
It even comes with a handy carrying case so you can take your foxy self anywhere. While it doesn’t have any fancy vibrating functions or an unusual shape, the weighted design ensures maximum pleasure with every use.
Plus, the flared base guarantees that it won’t disappear during play, no matter how intense things get.
PRICE：$26.99
PROS: Perfect for experienced users and those who enjoy anal stretching.
CONS: Not fully waterproof when the tail is attached.
Best Vibration – Frizz – Vibrating Butt Plug With Dog Tail
The Frizz stands out as the top vibrating choice among tail butt plugs, especially when you consider the quality of the plug at its price point. As Mary, who tested it, mentioned, “it’s pretty hard to beat.”
Mary was pleasantly surprised by the material of the plug, noting that although 5 ounces didn’t sound particularly heavy, it “feels pretty darn good too.” As someone with extensive experience using butt plugs, I can confirm that the added vibration usually improve the experience, and that’s exactly what our testers have reported.
Having never tried a tail butt plug before, Mariah found it “adorable” and appreciated that it’s available in several colors. She also liked that the long tail can be screwed on and off, which makes for easy cleaning and even allows for the option of using the plug without the tail.
PRICE：$35.99
PROS:
- Fun and playful design
- 10 Frequency Vibration
- 10 Meter Wireless Remote Control
CONS:
- Not fully waterproof when the tail is attached.
- Faux fur can shed
Best for Beginners – Cotton – Vibrating Bunny Tail
Olivia, who tested this tail butt plug set, found the “pink bunny tail” to be the most visually appealing, though her partner “really enjoyed the look” of the two longer tails.
Initially, Olivia was “more interested in the longer tails” as well, but she discovered they were “thick and bulky rather than cute and sexy.”
While she “enjoyed the dressing up/role play” aspect, there were a few issues with the set. Switching between the different tails was “a little tricky,” and unfortunately, the tail attachment broke. However, Olivia was able to “super glue the base back on,” though this led her to consider the “quality as mediocre at best.” Despite this, she believes “the price is still reasonable considering you get a remote control butt plug and three different tails.”
Regarding the plug’s vibrations, she noted they were “a little buzzy” but “very quiet.” One concern she raised was that the packaging doesn’t clarify whether the plug is waterproof, so I would recommend assuming it isn’t.
Overall, considering the price, this set offers great versatility, making it an excellent option for beginners.
PRICE：$26.99
PROS:
- Vibrating butt plug
- Whisper-Quiet Operation for Discreet Enjoyment
- Premium Quality with Food-Grade Silicone
CONS:
- Doesn’t state if plug is waterproof
Most Unique One – Pikachu – Vibrating Tail
For those new to anal play, the idea of inserting a large animal tail might seem intimidating. That’s where toys like the Pikachu come in, offering a more approachable introduction to kink.
Designed with a unique shape and size, this toy is coated in skin-safe silicone, making it suitable for all body types and compatible with any water-based lubricant. The pointed tip and mid-sized, wavy shaft allow for customizable pleasure and a tailored fit during insertion.
Understanding that beginners may want to explore different feelings, the Pikachu butt plug includes a vibrating bullet. Simply switch on the bullet for deep, rumbling stimulation, or remove it for a more natural feel. Whether in use or on display, this adorable plug stands out with its charming Pikachu tail design. And it’s fully waterproof for easy cleaning.
PRICE：$49.49
PROS:
- Pikachu fan
- Booty-shaking 10 Vibration Modes
- Premium Quality with Food-Grade Silicone
- Long Distance Vibrator Remote Control
CONS:
- Pricy
BEST FOR LUXURY – Unicorn Tailed Butt Plug
If you’re venturing into the world of tail butt plugs, the Unicorn Tailed Butt Plug is a luxury that might just spoil you for anything else. While it’s labeled as “beginner-friendly,” it sets such a high standard that future options might seem underwhelming.
This exquisite piece features a medical grade silicone plug, known for its durability and sleek finish, attached to a lush faux fur tail designed to mimic the look of a unicorn’s tail. The plug includes a flared base, providing safety and peace of mind during use, allowing you to explore without worrying about slippage or breakage.
Additionally, the non-porous surface is compatible with almost any lube, making it a highly adaptable addition to your collection.
In terms of size, the Unicorn Tailed Butt Plug boasts a total length of 21 inches, with a luxurious 17-inch tail and 4 inches of insertable length. The 4.5-inch girth provides a satisfying fill while remaining comfortable for most users.
PRICE：$32.39
PROS:
- Phthalate-Free for Your Safety
- Unique Unicorn Design
- Medical Grade Silicone Plug
CONS:
- Only One Option
