8 Best Fake Horse Sex Toys
Last Updated on October 22, 2025 by Nikita
Finding a good fake horse sex toy isn’t as simple as picking the biggest fantasy dildo you can find. After personally testing multiple designs—ranging from classic silicone horse dildos to horse butt plug toys —I learned quickly that these toys can be just as intense, challenging, and surprisingly technical as they are erotic. Some delivered a deep, stretching “full” sensation that hit every fantasy I had. A few, however, were awkward to handle, difficult to clean, or simply too harsh to enjoy for more than a few minutes.
This guide is not a commercial list written to praise every product. It’s my honest experience—what actually felt good, what fell short, and which features made the biggest difference (like suction base stability, silicone softness, curvature). Whether you’re into fantasy role-play, size exploration, or you’re just curious about horse design and more extreme stimulation, my goal is to help you choose safely and realistically. No drama. No sugar-coating. Just real results from real testing.
1.Anesidora Thrusting Horse Silicone Dildo
The design definitely leans into fantasy aesthetics — thick veins, a flared tip, and exaggerated shaping that clearly isn’t trying to look “human.” In the hand, the silicone felt soft on the surface but firm underneath, which I appreciated because floppy toys of this size can be annoying to control.
During my first test, the expansion + thrusting combo surprised me the most. The thrusting stroke is short — only a few centimeters — but when the expansion mode kicks in at the same time, it creates a deep pressure that actually feels fuller than I expected from a 4 cm diameter. The 7 modes range from slow and rhythmic to fast and aggressive. I enjoyed the mid-level settings most; the highest level felt a bit too mechanical and buzzy for my taste. The heating mode reaches a pleasant warmth, not “hot,” and the vibration is noticeably stronger near the base than the tip.
For fantasy play, it delivers a satisfying “filling” sensation, especially when riding it hands-free. However, I did run into a couple of drawbacks. First, it’s loud — not “vacuum cleaner loud,” but definitely not a toy you’d want to use with someone in the next room.
Price ： 46.99
Pros
- Strong thrusting + expansion combo creates unique pressure
- Remote works instantly and makes solo play easier
- Suction base is surprisingly stable
- Heating adds realism
Cons
- Louder than average when thrusting
Shop the Best Horse Dildo 、Check More Thrusting Dildo from Anesidora
2.The Flame – Super Huge Horse Dildo
Visually, it’s striking — a three-tone gradient of yellow, orange, and deep pink that fades into a dark, black-marbled suction base. The shape is unmistakably horse-inspired: a wide flared tip, long stretching shaft, and deep, raised ridges that run along the entire length.
The silicone has a dual-layer build — soft and squishy on the outside, firm at the core — which gives it a realistic “flesh compression” when you squeeze it. Despite its extreme size (mine was the large version, well over 40 cm long and 2.9–3.6 inches in usable girth), the shaft bends surprisingly well without losing structure, which helps a lot during insertion.
When I tested it, the first thing I noticed was the sheer weight and stretch. This toy isn’t pretending to be casual — it’s built for deep, slow, overwhelming fullness. The textures don’t simply glide; they pull and drag across you in waves, creating strong internal pressure even with small movements. Once fully warmed up, that sensation becomes addictive, but I had to take my time. The wide mid-shaft ridge is especially intense, and rushing would have made the session uncomfortable.
Price : $67.49 – $109.29
Pros
- Visually stunning fantasy design with bright gradient colors
- Dual-layer silicone feels premium and realistic
- Extreme stretch and fullness for size lovers
- Strong suction for hands-free riding
Cons
- Absolutely not beginner-friendly
Check Anesidora Dragon Dildo 、 Dog Dildo collection here
3.Nuckelavee – Horse Penis Sleeve With Spikes
It has a two-tone metallic finish, blending dark blue and silver at the base into a shimmering pink shaft, giving it a surreal, almost creature-like appearance. The surface is covered with raised bumps, thick ridges, and a flared fantasy glans, making it look like something between a spiked beast and a mutated stallion.
The silicone itself is soft, flexible, and very stretchy, so sliding it on is easy as long as you use lube on the inside. Once fitted, it grips well and doesn’t roll or slide around. On the outside, the texture is where this toy either becomes your favorite or not your style.
The soft silicone spikes don’t feel sharp or painful, but they create a very pronounced dragging and rubbing sensation during thrusting. For me, that sensation was intense in a good way — especially during slow thrusts — but it’s definitely not subtle.
The sleeve adds noticeable girth and a bit of extra length, and the built-in cock ring helps maintain firmness, which is a nice bonus. However, because the texture is so aggressive, this toy works best with lots of lube and a warmed-up partner. Used dry or too fast, the stimulation can easily cross from “intense” into “too much.”
Price : $53.99
Pros
- Beautiful, unique fantasy color design
- Soft silicone spikes create very intense texture
- Adds real girth and some length
- Snug fit with built-in ring for better control
- Easy to sanitize (boil-safe)
Cons
- Texture may be too intense for some
Shop the Best Fantasy Penis Sleeve from Fantasy Cock
4.Luminous Cock Extender Fantasy Horse
The glow-in-the-dark feature charged quickly under a lamp and lit up softly in the dark — a cool touch that added some atmosphere without being tacky.
My partner said the initial stretch was definitely something to adjust to — the added girth especially. We used a lot of lube, went slow, and communicated closely during the first few minutes. After getting used to the feel, he said it offered a “fuller” sensation than usual. He didn’t love the first few thrusts, but once we found a steady rhythm and I slowed down a bit, he started responding more positively.
He pointed out that the texture added a different kind of stimulation than we were used to. Not sharp or uncomfortable — just different. The visual aspect (with the glow) also made things feel more playful and less clinical, which he liked
Our second try went way smoother. I trimmed a bit more hair, added more lube, and spent more time during foreplay. Because we both knew what to expect, there was less fumbling and more focus. The sleeve warmed up with body heat and felt more natural as things went on. My partner reported less pressure and more enjoyment compared to our first session.
Price : $40.49
Pros
- Sturdy, body-safe silicone
- Stays in place with built-in ring
- Glow adds visual excitement
- Adds noticeable girth and length
- Easy to clean
- Good for stamina and control
Cons
- Slightly dulls sensation for the wearer
- May feel too large for some partners
5.Horse Doggy Style Fake Pussy
The material is soft and skin-like, with just enough firmness to keep structure. It has two distinct channels—a tighter anal tunnel and a slightly wider vaginal one. The internal textures feel incredible: bumps, ridges, and twisting nodes that create resistance and suction. The dual-channel design gives options depending on the mood—one side feels snug and pressure-heavy, the other more yielding and rhythmic.
During testing, I used a water-based lube and took it slow at first. Once the suction built up, the internal grip became more intense with each thrust. The feedback feels almost alive, especially if you adjust the angle or squeeze the sides for tighter friction. The weight helps too—it stays stable on a surface, which makes it great for hands-free use.
If you’re into fantasy aesthetics, this piece adds a psychological edge to the experience. There’s something primal and thrilling about the exaggerated design, and it definitely taps into that fantasy-driven mindset.
Price : $125.99
Pros:
- Dual-channel design for variety (vaginal + anal)
- Incredibly detailed internal texture
- Stable and weighty for hands-free use
- Visually striking fantasy craftsmanship
Cons:
- Heavy and not ideal for quick sessions
- Cleaning and drying take extra time
Shop the Best Animal pocket pussy、 Best Alien Pocket Pussy Here
You May Also Read :
6.Pegasus Unicorn – Fantasy Horse Animal Pussy
he weight, the sculpting, the horned tail and fantasy anatomy — it’s built for one thing: full-on fantasy immersion. If you enjoy getting lost in a theme, this toy makes it effortless.
The first thing that stood out is the weight (over 1kg). That heft actually works in its favor — it stays put during thrusting and has a more realistic, anchored feel versus lightweight pocket toys that slip around. The silicone is soft, stretchy, and almost gummy in a good way. It grips, then relaxes, then tightens again as you move, which gives it a far more lifelike sensation than smooth, plain tunnels.
The canal is tight and heavily textured. You can feel the bumps, folds, and ridges immediately on entry, and they create constant friction from tip to base — there are no “dead zones” where the sensation drops off. The internal structure forces consistent stimulation, which means this is not a toy where you can zone out. It keeps you engaged in every stroke, especially if you’re the kind who likes edging or slow thrusting to build intensity. With lube, it gets even better — the glide stays slick, but the textures remain very noticeable, which is exactly what you want in a fantasy stroker.
Pros:
- Heavy, anchored feel for hands-free or tabletop thrusting
- Extremely textured and highly stimulating internal canal
- Visually immersive design that boosts fantasy roleplay
- Soft, stretchy, premium silicone material
Cons:
- Heavier and less discreet than standard strokers
- Cleaning and drying require patience
7.Pony Butt Plug Pet Play
The Pony Butt Plug Tail is clearly designed for fantasy, roleplay, and aesthetic kink rather than raw stimulation alone. But after trying it, I realized it actually brings something unique to the bedroom: a psychological switch. The moment the tail is in, the mood changes. You stop thinking like a “viewer” and start playing a role. That’s the whole magic of this toy.
The plug itself is smooth, medium-sized, and beginner-friendly. The tapered tip makes insertion easy with lube, and the material has just enough flexibility to avoid discomfort while still feeling snug once it’s seated. At 4.3 inches insertable, it gives that “full” sensation without pushing into advanced territory. The stopper base is wide and safe, so there’s no fear of it slipping in too far.
It’s also worth noting that the tail hair looks impressive and feels soft. However, it does require extra care when cleaning — the plug is easy to wash, but the fiber tail needs to be rinsed gently and dried thoroughly to prevent tangling. So, cleanup is a bit more work compared to standard plugs.
Price : $23.39
Pros:
- Great size for beginners and intermediate users
- Creates instant psychological and erotic roleplay vibes
- Soft, swaying tail adds visual and fantasy appeal
- Comfortable shape and easy insertion
Cons:
- Tail requires careful cleaning and maintenance
- Not ideal for deep or advanced anal stimulation
8.Blaze – Squirting Horse Dildo
I tested the Large version, and even that felt massive going in. The first few minutes were about breathing, relaxing, and letting my body adjust to the stretch. The silicone is soft and flexible, which helps a lot — it bends with you rather than fighting against your angle or anatomy. Once I got fully seated, that full-to-the-core pressure hit, and it delivered exactly what this toy promises: depth, girth, and intensity.
The squirting feature is a fun bonus. It’s not a “must-have” for me personally, but I can’t deny that it adds a psychological kick — especially for fantasy roleplay. The manual pump gives you control over the timing, so you can build a scenario, edge with it, or time it for a climax moment. It’s messy, yes, but in a way that fits the fantasy.
The ribbed shaft is what pushed this toy from “just big” to “holy f***.” The texture drags against the walls with every thrust, and because of the sheer size, you feel everything. Combined with the weight and suction base, it works best as a hands-free toy — plant it on a smooth surface, back up to it slowly, and let gravity and motion do their job. When I got into a rhythm, the intensity went from overwhelming to euphoric. It delivered that deep, internal release you only get from toys that reach farther and stretch wider than anything realistic.
Price : $71.99–$89.09
Pros:
- Massive, fantasy-level fullness and stretch
- Ribbed texture adds powerful internal stimulation
- Squirting feature enhances roleplay and immersion
- Strong suction base for hands-free play
- Soft, flexible, body-safe silicone
Cons:
- Absolutely not for beginners
- Requires prep, warm-up, and plenty of lube
Shop Best ejaculating dildo from Anesidora
