7 Best Silicone Butt Plugs & Budget Friendly

Silicone is perhaps the best flexible material for sex toys, and it is an excellent option for butt plugs. It is because silicone is non-porous, body-safe, easy to clean, and semi-flexible; all of these features make it fantastic to use. Silicone butt plugs are also effortless to clean and maintain, as you can wash them with soap and water, a sex toy cleaner, and even clean them with boiling water. To help you make a good choice, we have tested a bunch of silicone butt plugs from our store inventory, and here we bring you a list of the best silicone butt plugs that will provide an unique experience.

Our Top Picks : Starfield – Wireless Vibrating Butt Plug

The Starfield Anal Vibe stands out as our top pick for silicone butt plugs, thanks to its exceptional design and features. Its slimline shape ensures easy insertion, while the broad T-shaped base offers safety and stability during use. The rounded tip enhances comfort, making it a high-quality choice for users.

This compact anal vibe isn’t just about form; it also delivers function with its 10-speed vibration settings, all controllable via a wireless remote. It’s USB rechargeable, ensuring hassle-free use, and made from body-safe, silky-smooth silicone compatible with water-based lubricants. Plus, it’s fully waterproof, allowing for versatile play in various settings.

Who It’s For

It is ideal for anyone seeking a high-quality silicone butt plug with a well-designed shape and top-notch features.

Price : $44.99

Best Value : Bling – 3PCS Anal Trainer Silicone Jeweled

The Bling Silicone Plug impressed us during testing with its thoughtful design and high-quality materials, all at an affordable price. Its ergonomic shape is optimized for easy insertion, featuring a wide body for a comfortable stretch, a slim neck for secure placement, and a heart-shaped base with a faux gem that adds a touch of glamour.

Made from silky-smooth silicone, this plug is non-porous, body-safe, and phthalate-free. It’s lightweight, making it ideal for extended wear, and is compatible with water-based lubricants. The plug is also suitable for temperature play and easy to clean.

Who It’s For

It is perfect for anyone seeking a well-crafted silicone butt plug that offers both quality and comfort.

Price : $33.29

Best for Beginners ： Cookie – Butt Plug Vibes 3PCS

The Cookie Beginner Plug stands out as an excellent choice for those new to silicone butt plugs. Its design is tailored for easy insertion, featuring a tapered tip, a slightly wider body, a narrow neck, and a broad base that make sure safe use. The base also functions as a suction cup, adding extra versatility.

Crafted entirely from body-safe silicone, this plug is compatible with water-based lubricants. We appreciate its suitability for temperature play, as it can be heated or cooled for unique sensations. The non-porous, silky-smooth silicone is free from phthalates, paraffin, and latex, and it’s easy to clean—just rinse with soap and water, use a sex toy cleaner, or pop it in the dishwasher.

Who It’s For

Cookie is ideal for beginners, thanks to its easy-to-use shape and high-quality platinum-cured silicone construction.

Price : $42.29

Best Silicone Butt Plug Kit : Crystal – Anal Training Kit

Why We Picked It

We chose the Crystal For Her – Jeweled Butt Plug as this is an excellent silicone butt plug kit. It consists of three butt plugs in increasing sizes – a small, medium, and large plug, each in a purple color. These feature a spade-like shape that is optimized for easy insertion and smooth use. But we also found these exciting to use, especially for beginners, as the smallest one is relatively easy to use and fits first-time users.

The bases of the Crystal Trainer Set plugs all feature beautiful faux gems that add some sparkle to your fun. We also love that these are encased in seamless silicone that is non-porous, phthalate-free, latex-free, fragrance-free, waterproof, and compatible with water-based lubes.

Who It’s For

The Fantasy For Her – Her Little Gems Trainer Set is ideally suited for beginners and gentle players looking for silicone butt plugs that are optimized for easy insertion.

Price : $42.29

Best Tail Silicone Butt Plug : Frizz – Vibrating Plug With Tail

Role-play becomes even more immersive with the right accessories, and the Frizz Fox Tail Butt Plug is perfect for indulging your animal fetish. This butt plug is made from body-safe silicone, offering flexibility and comfort. Its tapered shape ensures easy insertion, while the broad base prevents over-insertion, ensuring safe use.

The real highlight is the 15-inch long white fox tail attached to the base, which is soft and luxurious, adding a playful element to your experience. Additionally, the base features a silicone loop designed to hold a vibrating bullet, allowing you to enhance your playtime with stimulating vibrations. We enjoyed testing the Frizz Fox Tail Butt Plug, finding it easy to clean and maintain.

Who It’s For

The Frizz Fox Tail Butt Plug is for all the people who have an animal fetish and want to use a silicone butt plug with a fox tail. The vibrations from the small bullet vibe are an extra perk.

Price : $35.99

Also Read

Best Butt Plug Tails – Tested by Sexpert

Best App-Controlled Silicone Butt Plug : Mr Play – Big Rimming Butt Plug

We included theMr Play on our list because it’s truly an exceptional product. The plug features a tapered design that makes insertion easy and comfortable, while the secure base ensures it stays in place. Made from smooth, velvety, body-safe silicone, the Hush 2 is also compatible with water-based lubricants for added comfort.

What really sets this butt plug apart is its vibrating capability and app control via the app, allowing you to customize vibrations and patterns to suit your preferences. It’s USB rechargeable, waterproof, and easy to clean. Available in four different sizes, It caters to users of all experience levels, brings a versatile choice for anyone.

Who It’s For

TheMr Play is perfect for anyone seeking a high-quality silicone butt plug with an optimized design and a wide range of customizable vibrating patterns.

Price : $71.99

Best Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug : Siren – Remote Vibrating Prostate Massager

The Siren with Remote Control stands out as one of the most enticing vibrating butt plugs we’ve tested. Its sleek, anatomically designed shape provides a delightful experience upon insertion, with a blunt tip leading to a broader body. The slim neck connects to a T-shaped base that sits comfortably outside the anus.

This plug doesn’t just look good—it vibrates, too. You can easily switch between ten vibration modes using the buttons on the base or the included wireless remote control. The plug is USB rechargeable and fully waterproof, making it versatile for various settings. It’s crafted from body-safe silicone, which is also waterproof and compatible with water-based lubricants. Cleaning is a breeze with soap and water, and it’s recommended to store it separately from other silicone toys.

Who It’s For

It is perfect for those seeking a premium silicone butt plug with a sexy, ergonomic design and customizable vibrations.

You May Also Like

8 Best Inflatable Butt Plugs – Safe & Real Tested！

7 Best Glass Butt Plugs to Buy in 2024